NOMO'S PAST HEADLINES                                  Bulletin board of the latest developments 

 
April 2010
Serious Concern
As a result of a recent FOIA, information was released that gives serious concern that the information provided to the public at the August 20, 2009 public forum and still posted online, was not truthful.  The abandoned May Whitney Report and the powerpoint presentation pertinent slides are 22, 23, and 40 (see below).


 

May_Whitney_Forum_08202009


March 2010

EPA Indoor Air Quality Tools for School Program Webinar

Don't miss this exciting opportunity!
Finding Solutions: The Virtual Walk Through Webinar
Thursday, March 25, 2010 at 1pmET
Register Today!




March 2010
The School Board and Administration have scheduled a Community Forum for Thursday, March 18th from 7:00-9:00pm at Middle School South.  Community members may present q
uestions in person or in writing at the forum, or via email from home during the webcast.  Emails may be sent to Forum@lz95.org; this mailbox will be available for questions and comments through March 18th, 2010.
 
 Pass the word....


December, 2009

 
EPA developed the Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) Tools for Schools (TfS) Program to reduce exposures to indoor environmental contaminants in schools through the voluntary adoption of sound indoor air quality management practices.

The IAQ Tools for Schools Program is a comprehensive resource to help schools maintain a healthy environment in school buildings by identifying, correcting, and preventing IAQ problems. Poor indoor air quality can impact the comfort and health of students and staff, which, in turn, can affect concentration, attendance, and student performance. In addition, if schools fail to respond promptly to poor IAQ, students and staff are at an increased risk of short-term health problems, such as fatigue and nausea, as well as long-term problems like asthma.

Since its release in 1995 (just re-released this year), the IAQ TfS Action Kit has been implemented in hundreds of schools across the country. School districts that have implemented IAQ TfS find that there are common elements to successfully implementing the program. 

  1. Organizing a program with a committed group of individuals dedicated to ensuring good IAQ and with clear support from senior management
  2. Assessing current IAQ conditions and issues
  3. Creating a Plan outlining a strategic approach to identifying, resolving, and preventing IAQ problems
  4. Taking Actions to improve IAQ in the school that lead to increased student and staff health and productivity
  5. Evaluating the IAQ management program by tracking and assessing results
  6. Communicating the intent, results, and next steps of the IAQ management program

The IAQ TfS Program assists school districts in identifying the actions they can take to successfully plan and implement and effective IAQ management Program.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

October, 2009

Good News! This week the Board of Education granted access to CRA into May Whitney Elementary. CRA will have unfettered access to conduct their environmental assessment of the building. The assessment will take place in the coming weeks taking into account weather conditions. We found ourselves smiling and nodding in agreement while listening to their discussion. They acknowledge the concerns of the community and the reasons for the concerns. A Board Member commented that granting access will provide checks and balances. We could not have agreed more. Please stay tuned and thank you for your support in helping to make this happen! 

========================================================
October, 2009
It is exciting to see another group of concerned parents looking to further advance the effort to insure healthy indoor air quality for May Whitney Elementary.  This group submitted a proposal to the school district to utilize a third party environmental company to insure the district's test results for the safety of our children.  Below is the proposal.
This group of parents is asking for your support by e-mailing our Board Members to encourage them to grant access.  The Board can be contacted by e-mail at dist95boe@lz95.org.   Or, if you prefer, you may respond to No Mold Left Behind at 95.nomoldleftbehind.com showing your support.
Thank you for your continued interest in insuring a healthy indoor environment for our children.
 ================================================================
PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO SCHOOL DISTRICT, 10/6/09
Conestoga-Rovers & Associates understands that in the past the District had retained its own environmental contractors to conduct indoor environmental assessments at the May Whitney Elementary School (School) prior to its reopening.  We acknowledge the request of the concerned parents that an independent indoor environmental assessment be performed at the School by a licensed environmental contractor and that Conestoga-Rovers & Associates (“CRA”) has been selected for this task.  Thank you for this opportunity.
In order to submit a meaningful proposal CRA will need the District to agree to allow CRA to first perform a cursory visual inspection of the School to verify the findings and conclusions outlined in the reports prepared by the District’s environmental contractors regarding the School’s indoor environmental condition.
In its inspection of the School, CRA will generally look for anything that may support mold or bacterial growth at an unacceptable health and safety level.  During this initial visit to the School, CRA will not perform any invasive or destructive testing and will endeavor to arrange its site visit so as not to interfere with the School’s normal operations.
  While on site, CRA will require a custodial or similarly knowledgeable person from the School to provide access to all floors, closets and ancillary spaces throughout the building, including areas of the School that service the HVAC system and supply access to the roof.  This person should also be able provide access to maintenance records throughout the project and allow the use of an appropriate-sized ladder to allow CRA to look for any environmental issues that the District’s contractors may have not noticed or had not existed during their previous inspections. CRA will require a person within the school to act as a single point of contact for information during this project.
 Following the inspection, CRA intends submit a proposal to the parent group.  Items to be included in the proposal are costs associated with:
-Critical review of the previous studies that are provided to CRA;
-Identified potential gaps and uncertainties in the previous studies;
-Address any new issues if identified;
-If required, outline a focused testing plan;
-Generate a letter report of CRA’s findings and recommendations.
 
As stated above, the purpose of this environmental assessment is to provide an independent verification of the findings and conclusions made by the District’s environmental contractors.  If CRA agrees with the District’s contractors and does not believe further work is required, the concerned parents will be informed of this finding.  If CRA is of the opinion that further testing or assessment may be needed, we will discuss our proposed next steps within the proposal and with the appropriately identified parties so we may proceed in concert.
The initial walk through inspection would be performed by a Certified Industrial Hygienist, licensed by the state of IL to conduct such activities, and performed at the sole cost of CRA.  There will be no requirement to proceed with the proposal by either party.
Thank you for this opportunity to provided this service.  CRA’s Statement of Qualifications are available upon request.  I am committed to a project at least the end of this week.  Please contact me early next week to set a schedule for the walk through.
Conestoga-Rovers & Associates
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


May Whitney Community Forum 8/20/09

Forum Video:

http://www.lz95.org/Media/media.htm

Originally Recorded on Thursday, August 20 at 7:00 pm
(Playback approx 3 hours)

 

Daily Herald Newspaper Article:

Parents want more testing of May Whitney

"We have openly stated that what we do in this district is Band-Aid our facilities," she (Kathy Brown, President of Board of Education) said.

Five days before the start of the new school year, tensions ran high about the environmental quality of May Whitney Elementary School in Lake Zurich.

At a community forum on the topic Thursday night, Lake Zurich Unit District 95 officials and representatives from independent agencies that have tested the facility attested to the building's safety.

Voices were raised as some parents were not convinced of the building's safety and criticized officials for taking a reactive response to the issue.

"This is not a reactive situation," said Board of Education President Kathy Brown. "People have been very proactive about these situations. We moved out of (the former May Whitney building)."

Brown did acknowledge the district is facing many issues with old facilities but cannot do everything because of a tight budget. She said doing everything the board would want to would cost $35 million to $40 million.

"We have openly stated that what we do in this district is Band-Aid our facilities," she said.

Small amounts of asbestos-containing materials are present in pipe insulation in mechanical rooms, some vinyl floor tiles and mastic and some bricks, but none has been found in the air.

But some inaccessible areas above ceilings have not been tested and roof leaks have parents concerned that if there is asbestos up there, it could be disturbed and create health hazards.

"We don't know if we have (issues) in those inaccessible areas, so all that we have are these air quality tests," said local parent Eileen Maloney, as she asked officials to do more testing.

The facility, also known as the Annex, has been the home of May Whitney since 2007. The elementary school's original location flooded in 2007, eventually revealing the presence of asbestos and stachybotrys, a toxic strain of mold.

The current location formerly housed a middle school and had been used for storage since 2007. The portion of the building that houses May Whitney is 55 years old and the unused portion of the building is 80 years old.

School: Parents concerned about asbestos

http://www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=315288&src=61 


========================================

Depending on what you find during the walk-through inspection, there are several different steps you may need to take to help solve the problem. You may find it necessary to hire one or more professionals to fix, or to further identify, the problems. For example, you may need a mechanical engineer, a heating, ventilation and air conditioning expert, a cleaning and restoration professional, an industrial hygienist, or some other type of consultant. 

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has developed an innovative program called Tools for Schools that can assist schools in identifying and addressing IEQ problems. To learn more about the program or to obtain a kit, please go to http://www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/tools4s2.html.

 

For more information about IEQ, visit the Illinois Department of Public Health Web site topics list at

www.idph.state.il.us/a-zlist.htm

 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IDPH's Fact Sheet.   
 School Indoor Environmental Quality:
Testing Should Not be the First Step
 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
DPH Letter to Assistant Superintendent
Dated December 29, 2008:
 
``````````````````````````````````````````````
 
December 18, 2008
 School Board planning summer projects: By STEPHANIE KOHL skohl@pioneerlocal.com

"We've not been taking care of that building for some time." Kalou said. 

Even with snow on the ground, School District 95 officials are already planning for upcoming summer repairs.

"There's nothing remotely glamorous on this list," said Mary Kalou, assistant superintendent of business and operations. "Some of these things are basic functions to be able to run the school(s)."

The list of summer work, which will be financed using the Capital Projects fund, includes repairs at all of the district's schools and with projects such as replacing the boilers and pumps and reconfiguring to recapture six classrooms at May Whitney, minor classroom remodeling of the band room at Sarah Adams, computer room alterations for 27 student stations at Seth Paine, classroom remodeling at Middle School South and Isaac Fox as well as Middle School North and Spencer Loomis and replacing the floor of the Performing Arts Center at the high school.

Repairs are estimated at about $2.8 million total, but the district hasn't gone to bid for the work. Kalou expects the majority of the work will be bid together in March. She hopes to get good prices because it is a larger project and, with the current state of the economy, contractors are hurting for work. "We're only doing what we have to do," Kalou said. "We'd like to do more, but we don't have the money."

The Board of Education discussed potential costs associated with keeping Charles Quentin open. The school is slated to close at the end of the current school year. Kalou said the district would have to replace the gym roof at a cost of at least $100,000 and address boiler room problems. She predicted at least an additional $50,000 in urgent life safety repairs would also be needed.

Operational costs to keep the school running for another year would be more than $300,000, said Superintendent Brian Knutson.

"We've not been taking care of that building

for some time." Kalou said.   

 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
First Anniversary for New May Whitney

 

Our thanks to Representative Ed Sullivan Jr. for his diligence in assisting our community group in bringing the Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) into the New May Whitney for an investigation of possible moisture and mold problems.  We turned to him a year ago, when suddenly May Whitney School was closed due to chronic flooding and the discovery of toxic mold. The Annex was reopened and converted to the New May Whitney School. 

 

All along it was our goal to get governmental agencies into the building to determine whether or not there was a moisture or mold problem.  It was finally in July 2008 that the IDPH investigated the building.  Thus far the district administration and Board of Education have relied on mold testing that according to the IDPH was unreliable and could not establish that the indoor air quality in the New May Whitney was acceptable and safe.

 

There are two parts of IDPH’s recent investigation of May Whitney, the first for moisture and mold (conducted in July of this year) and the second will address the ventilation system in October or November (when the windows are closed and the building is occupied).

 

For a summary of IDPH’s recommendations for May Whitney, see Health Questionnaire Summary and Inspection Summary, found on our IL Dept of Public Health page, along with the full reports and the district’s responsePlease take a few minutes to review these informative and important documents.

 

We’d also like to thank the more than 600 community members who supported our petition.   It was unfortunate that a full year of persistence was even necessary, but it was.  Our administration and Board of Education attempted to make us out to be fanatics.  Rather, we are thorough; children’s health was dependent on it.

 

District 95 schools are in a difficult situation right now.  We acknowledge that with the discovery of the structural problems at several buildings, the administration and board have their hands full, but we stand by our stance that the May Whitney community deserves a safe and healthy building for our children.  We have just learned that Representative Sullivan has provided a grant in the amount of $55,000 to District 95 earmarked specifically for “School Facility Repairs.”  We think this is a timely development.

 

The IDPH reports make several suggestions to the district on how to ensure that May Whitney is a safe environment for students and staff.  It is our sincere hope that they will follow those suggestions ensuring that they do indeed put safety first. 

 

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
Monday, May 12, 2008: 
 
Response received today from Dr. Richard L. Lipsey, Toxicologist regarding the ENVIRON International Corporation report entitled, Mold Inspection and Testing - May Whitney Elementary School, March, 2008:
 
This report does not match the photos showing numerous significant water intrusion problems. I have never seen such low mold levels in the air in a school, after 36 years of sampling schools nationwide coast to coast. Environ reported from 0, 0, 0, 0, 1 (assuming their multiplication factor of 17, or only looking at 1/17th of the plate.) The air data looks impossible. NIOSH recommends that a large fan be used in rooms that are unoccupied to get the spores off the floor. did they do that? Did they sample properly with the proper methods and materials? I have taught proper sampling for many years at two universities.
 
I am not sure I can believe the carpet vacuum samples either. It does not match the photos. I suspect there are significant levels of mold in the school. Where are the bacteria results? Who monitored Environ when they sampled the school?
 
Dr. Richard L. Lipsey   ( 904 ) 398 - 2168
550 Water St, #1230, Jacksonville, FL 32202
Toxicologist and former Univ. Florida professor &
Adj Prof, Univ. N. FL, OSHA HazMat certification,
Fla. Comm. College Jax, Institute of Occ. Safety & Health, Chairman,
Clinical Tox Advisory Comm, Florida Poison Info Center, Jax.
Society of Toxicology & American College of Toxicology
www.richardlipsey.com

  Sign in   Recent Site Activity   Terms   Report Abuse   Print page  |  Powered by Google Sites